iPad vs Kindle -As far as e-book reading, how does the iPad, Apple’s tablet computer compare to Amazon Kindle, a dedicated e-book reader?
The quick answer: The standalone e-book reader is still very much alive. Kindle is more portable and costs less than iPad; however, iPad is still a good e-book device.
That sums up our side-by-side look at the e-reader potential of the iPad (selling price $499+) and the Kindle ($260) which held up outstandingly in our e-reader evaluations. Take a look at our Amazon Kindle versus Apple iPad showdown footage (on the right) on YouTube’s Consumer Reports channel.
Here is a comparison of the 2 devices as eReaders.
iPad vs Kindle round 1: iPad Wins
The Apple iBooks app displays your titles on a virtual bookshelf with the actual book covers visible. After you choose a title, it is simple to turn the pages. If you are impressed by fancy virtual page turns, you will like iPad, which adds a virtual curl to the page and renders the actual type on the underside with near perfection. You can even vary the time it takes to turn pages, from being quicker than even the Kindle, to slow.
An illuminated color display.
Even though color isn’t necessary to read most books, it is good to use for covers and colorful pictures, which the iPad’s excellent screen shows clearly. Kindle’s eInk screen has no color, but this is the norm for e Reader screens these days. It does rely on ambient light; whereas, iPad has a backlit LCD screen that can be read in the dark.
Readily connect with several booksellers.
It may come as a surprise that, with its standard resistance to letting the competition get wise to its devices, Apple has let e-book applications from Kindle, Barnes & Noble, and more onto the iPad. Nonetheless, the majority are only in iPhone versions so far and these require enlargement to fill the iPad’s screen.
Perhaps Apple let the competition exist because iBooks has a smaller number of titles than Kindle or B&N for the time being. Furthermore, they may not want a limited library to cause iPad owners to be unhappy.
If you want an e-book from any place other than Kindle’s store, you have to connect your Kindle to a computer using a USB cable and convert the book to the Kindle format.
iPad vs Kindle round 2: Kindle Wins
Type that is the easiest to read.
The Kindle’s type is much clearer than the iPad’s, though it is sufficient. The iPad is a little harder on your eyes because of its bluish background. Kindle’s brownish/green background is easier on the eyes.
Light-weight, and small in size.
The size of the Kindle’s 6-inch screen is comparable to many paperback books, which enables the model to be effortlessly taken along in a purse. Conversely, the iPad (and the $489 Kindle DX) come with 10-inch displays that are larger than the typical reader requires and need to be transported in a large carrying case. The 6″ Kindle weighs approximately 10 ounces; whereas, the iPad weighs all of 24 ounces.
It costs less.
The price for the Kindle is $259, which includes unlimited 3G book purchases anywhere and at anytime. iPad prices start at $499, going up to $629 for a model with 3G access. On top of that are monthly, optional 3G charges that range from $15 to $30 if you want to use 3G capability.
iPad vs Kindle round 3: Kindle Wins
The bottom line
Basically, iPad has a lot more versatility than Kindle, and this keeps growing every day as applications are added. Some great applications on iPad are interactive newspapers and magazines, and there is a lot more to explore. If you want to be able to do lots of things with your device, and you have a budget of about $500, you will want an iPad.
However, if you just want to read e-books, Kindle is more affordable choice. It is also easier to read and smaller. For the time being, it is the better choice for most e-book aficionados.
Kindle vs Nook vs iPad – Here we compare Kindle, Nook, and iPad in order to find out the answer to the most frequently asked question regarding eReaders: “Which one is best?” Remember when the release of Apple iPad in April of 2010 caused a lot of people to say that there was no longer a place for dedicated eBook readers in the consumer world?
They thought that Amazon Kindle would soon be out of business. However, a year has passed and eBook readers are still popular. In addition, companies continue to update the technology and introduce new ones, such as the most recent versions of Nook and Kindle. But how big are the differences between these e-book readers, the iPad, and other tablets? Let’s see the facts.
Kindle vs Nook vs iPad — Size and Weight
Among the first items to consider when picking an ebook reader is the reading comfort. Clearly, the fact that you are weighing all your options shows that you are a serious book lover. So stated, the comfort level during a long session of reading depends very much on the unit’s size and weight.
Clearly, all you have to do is examine the specifics listed to see which choice is the best in this category. The most up to date Kindle has a smaller and thinner frame, at only 7.5” x 4.8” x 0.335”, than the others. Additionally, the most recent Kindle is the lightest, weighing in at just 8.7 ounces.
The Nook is somewhat bigger and weighs more, while the iPad, which is quite thin, is the largest and weighs 1.5 lbs (nearly three times the weight of the Kindle). The iPad is an excellent choice for all kinds of eBook reading. Whether you just take it along to be sure you always have something to read or you plan to read for extended periods of time, it is up to the task.
Kindle vs Nook vs iPad — Display
iPad has some fantastic features. Whether or not they are suitable for you will depend upon your needs and preferences in reading materials. I’m referring to iPad’s 9.7-inch LED-backlit full color high resolution IPS display.
Without all the jargon, what you really need to know is that it is really enjoyable to read an iPad display screen. iPad also does a great job on other functions such as: Games, Twitter, Facebook, video playback, web browsing, and a variety of other applications. Nonetheless, when evaluating based upon the performance of this type of display for dedicated reading, you could not say that it’s perfect. An exception might be glossy magazines with lots of pictures and color-filled children’s books.
Basically, Kindle and Nook’s 6-inch e-ink screens are a little bit dull when compared with the brightness of the iPad. Nevertheless, most consumers choose them for lengthy reading because of reduced eye strain. This sort of screen is glare free even under direct sunlight.
Even though both eReaders use e-ink technology, Amazon’s ebook reader is still out in front of Barnes & Noble’s Nook. The reason for this is that the Kindle currently utilizes the latest-generation Pearl E-ink. This delivers 50% better contrast when compared to earlier models.
Another choice is the Nook Color Edition, which was released toward the end of 2010. This choice has a 7″ color LCD touchscreen. It is called the Readers Tablet by Barnes & Noble. The reason for this is that it has a lot of functionality when compared with other eReaders; however, it is not as functional as a tablet PC.
Kindle vs Nook vs iPad — User Interface
To navigate Kindle, you must use a physical keyboard, a five-way controller, and a variety of buttons. It serves its purpose very well; even though, it is not quite as quick and easy as using a touch device such as iPad.
Naturally, the iPad’s animation effect, which gives the feeling of “physically” turning pages, makes it very cute and attractive. However, aside from that, touch technology doesn’t really add a lot to the ebook reader capabilities of this unit. Uniquely, Nook has a dual screen combination. It has a 5″ eInk screen for reading. Beneath that is a 3.5″ screen with LCD touch for navigation. You will find the Previous and Next buttons along the frames’ sides.
The device is bright and colorful thanks to the small color display screen; however, it takes a bit of practice to navigate in the lower screen. This is especially true if you are used to touch devices such as iPhone. Nook’s color version, like the iPad, has full touch technology. This makes it easy to arrange content over the whole screen and turn pages quickly.
Kindle vs Nook vs iPad — Books & File Formats
All of the devices we are reviewing are capable of reading a number of text file formats. PDF is the format most commonly used for this purpose. Kindle’s proprietary file format (AZW) makes it impossible to read books from Amazon without first installing a device with your Kindle application.
Unlike the other two choices, Kindle does not support EPUB, which is the standard file format used for the majority of open eBooks. Because EPUB compatibility equates with the ability to borrow books from online libraries and download free content such as Google books, this is actually a pretty major consideration.
You can find plenty of books to read on all three of these eReaders, but Nook has the biggest selection. NookBooks carries more than two-million titles. There are 800,000 titles in the Kindle store. There are just 150,000 titles in the Apple iBookStore. No matter which eBook reader you get, you are sure to be able to enjoy popular books and best sellers from many fine eBook stores.
Kindle vs Nook vs iPad — Functionality
The main thing we will be comparing in this review of iPad, Nook, and Kindle is book reading; however, all have other functions that we will touch upon. It is always true that many people want a device that will do it all, including eReading, as opposed to a dedicated eReader.
The iPad was designed to do it all, so it is clearly the best in this respect. If you don’t really read a lot, you can still find a lot to do with iPad. You can use Twitter, Facebook, play games, watch videos and movies, surf the net and more.
Both Kindle and Nook have built-in web browsers. They also have some games. Nonetheless, these are fairly experimental features for these devices. The gray-scale e-ink display each provides actually poses several limitations on function. Though doing better for things like that, the Nook cannot begin to compare with the iPad.
Kindle vs Nook vs iPad — Price
In the final analysis, we compare Kindle vs Nook vs iPad in regards to cost. Nook and Kindle are both very affordable and are priced within $10 of each other. You will pay $149 for Wi-Fi only versions of Nook. Kindle Wi-Fi only costs $139. Kindle Wi-Fi + 3G models cost $199 and $189 respectively. Starting prices for iPad are approximately $499 (Wi-Fi only version). For the Wi-Fi and 3G model the price is $629.
Kindle vs Nook vs iPad — What’s The Best Deal?
We’ve just looked at the Kindle vs Nook vs iPad and their respective advantages and disadvantages. Lightest and most compact is Kindle. The iPad is definitely the spiffiest and includes a tremendous amount of functionality.
Nook straddles the fence. It is especially important to take the Nook Color into consideration. The main thing you should decide is whether you want a dedicated eReader or a device that does everything, including reading eBooks.
Even though the iPad costs more (and thus may discourage some buyers) it is important to realize that it also delivers more, and you get what you pay for. Simultaneously, many people may feel that it is too costly to spend $150 on a device (such as Kindle or Nook) that is only meant for reading eBooks. If you read a great deal, this price may well be worth it to you.
Kindle vs Kindle DX Features:
In order to decide which is the better e-reader, the original Amazon Kindle or the Kindle DX, we need to evaluate what they have to offer. Using the following criteria, we did a comparison of the Kindle and the Kindle DX: display size, device size, battery life, connectivity feature, price. The two Kindle devices are different by the features they offer.
The Kindle DX boasts a significantly larger screen; it measures 9.7 inches diagonally, compared to Kindle’s 6-inch screen. Users should realize that because Kindle emphasizes the diagonal display, it does not support landscape mode. It stands to reason that because of the difference in size between these two devices, they differ in other features as well. So, which is superior? Large or tiny? When it comes to reading ebooks, it goes without saying that a larger display will result in a better reading experience.
The Kindle DX’s larger display uses more battery energy. This is why the battery like of the Kindle is still superior to the Kindle DX. With wireless connectivity turned off, the Kindle can last for a month, while the Kindle DX lasts 2-3 weeks.
When the wireless connectivity is on, the Kindle provides 3 weeks of battery life while the DX provides 7 days. While we are on the subject of wireless connectivity, the Kindle only provides WiFi while the Kindle DX has both 3G and WiFi. Naturally, the Kindle DX is superior to the Kindle in this area.
Lastly, the key consideration when purchasing a new Kindle and which model to get – the cost. Once again, because the Kindle DX is larger, it costs more than the Kindle. The original Kindle sells for $139 and the Kindle DX is $379.
Kindle vs Kindle DX – Performance
I was lucky to get to try out both Kindle varieties. When I first tried the original Kindle, I was stunned. This was way before the iPad was introduced; it was the first tablet gadget I had ever used. At that moment, I knew that the Amazon Kindle was a revolutionary device. Then the Kindle DX debuted.
The DX is superior to the original device in a number of ways, and it runs just as fast as the Kindle when a person is reading an ebook, downloading books from the Amazon Kindle store and skimming through virtual pages of ebooks. I knew immediately that the future of the Amazon Kindle was the Kindle DX. The original Kindle accomplished what it needed to. The Kindle DX should be given the star treatment today.
Kindle vs Kindle DX – The Similarities
Native PDF formats are supported by both the Kindle and the Kindle DX. Therefore, if you are not interested in obtaining books via Amazon, it is possible to find free content on the Internet that you can read on your Kindle. Amazon’s Whispersync technology, text-to-speech, portrait and landscape view, and e-ink technology are supported by both Kindle devices.
Kindle vs Kindle DX- Which one is the superior eBook Reader?
Even though it is fairly obvious that the Kindle DX has more features than the original, it does not necessarily follow that the Kindle DX is better than the Kindle. Each has their advantages and disadvantages. The Kindle DX weighs more than the Kindle so a few people might prefer the lighter model. Certainly many features come into play when one is trying to determine which eBook reader is best, but we will let you make your own determination as to which one is the best for you.
Kindle DX or iPad – Make beautiful eBooks in little time. Give it try without paying for it. Download right this minute! The iPad and the Kindle are both remarkable e-readers, but which one is the best choice? With this Kindle DX versus iPad evaluation, you will learn all of the good and bad things about each unit so you can choose between the two!
Features – iPad Rating
The iPad might be the most total and stunning device ever made, along with the iPhone. What are the reasons? Truthfully, it has a very responsive 9.7 inch touchscreen, a stunning metallic finish, and millions of application to meet your needs.
The top features include
• Videos and Youtube: access to view the youtube video (or movies) you desire, any time, is just wonderful. The truth is that the screen is extremely clear and sharp which enhances the experience.
• E-Mail, Social Networking, Web-surfing: It is quite simple to use iPad to read your e-mail. Web-browsing should be quite familiar; it is possible to utilize multitouch gestures (such as zoom and pinch) so that the experience is as smooth as possible.
• Specialized apps are available for checking Facebook and Twitter; best of all, this can be done while lying in bed–or even while you are on the bus if you have a 3G connection!
• iBooks: The iPad also functions very well as an e-book reader. The page turning animation appears very life like and text is bright and clear. The biggest downside is reading in bright sunlight is out of the question, so the Kindle DX is the winner on this point.
Features – Kindle RX Rating
The Kindle DX has one sole purpose and that is for reading.
A web browser is included which allows you to access the Internet if you so desire (although it’s nothing to write home about and definitely not as good as that of the iPad). You can also utilize it to read PDF documents, but its primary purpose is as a true e-ink device.
It is better than the iPad when used in this manner, as it feels more like a book and it doesn’t cause as much strain on the eyes. Kindle has a few advantages over the iPad including its smaller size, light weight, and simplicity to read even when in the sun.
Performance – Kindle DX or iPad
The Kindle was designed just for reading books, which makes it simple and easy to use.
Performance is far more critical for iPad, so how well does its 1 Ghz processor function? Truthfully, it runs extremely well and just about all apps perform quickly without issues. The processing of the graphic is shockingly good (be prepared for top-quality visuals!) and video play is good.
My only complaint is that if your device is jailbroken and you utilize the Backgrounder app, sometimes your iDevice will crash due to the small RAM memory available (256 MB). This will probably not be an issue in the next iOs 4.X versions, however. If your iPad has not been jailbroken, it is not a problem.
Cost – Kindle DX or iPad
While the iPad is quite polished and complete, this quality comes at a price (as is the case with most gadgets produced by Apple).
With a price tag of $499, the Wi-Fi-only 16 GB version is ideal for those who merely wish to enjoy the benefits of the device without paying for a 3G connection. The priciest model is the 64 GB 3G-enabled version that sells for $829. This is meant for executives who are truly interested in utilizing their iPads to their fullest potential.
The Amazon Kindle has a much smaller price tag – approximately $379.
Bottom Line – Kindle DX or iPad
The Kindle DX is the device for you if you are merely interested in reading e-books (even though the iPad’s iBooks app is quite solid as well). However, the Kindle DX is less costly and far easier to read in bright light.
If you are interested in a unique “touchscreen laptop” that allows you to do a number of things no matter where you are (like writing this article!), then you will have to pay little more money. But you won’t regret it.
Kindle Kobo Nook Faceoff – The eBook revolution is here to stay. Amazon recently announced that digital eBooks had set a record by outselling hardcovers. They are expected to outsell paperbacks shortly. Nonetheless, the types of devices we currently use for reading this sort of book (smartphone, tablet computer, digital e reader) are not necessarily the end of the line in the technology development.
Last holiday season, we examined the most popular e-readers available to shoppers. Since that time, a number of companies have made minor changes in their lineups by adding some new additions and implementing some serious price-drops. All of this has provided quite a bit more choice in eReaders.
Oh, and we can’t forget the iPad thing.
It seemed, at first, like the iPad was going to cause an extreme change in the e-reader market. Recent sales have been through the roof, but E-ink readers have experienced the same popularity. When we compiled this revised roundup, we questioned whether or not to include the iPad. Apple has announced a new (magic) category for iPad, claiming that it is an entirely new breed of device.
Aside from all of the hype, this writer tends to agree. Among e-readers, iPad is unique in that it is actually a multimedia device that includes the capacity to be used as an e-reader. Without taking into account any of its other features, as an e-reader, the iPad does not hold up well against its competitors. There can be some eye strain over long periods of looking at the screen which can be difficult in brighter light. It weighs about three times as much as the average e-reader and has a significantly shorter battery life (10 hours compared to several weeks for most ereaders).
One important piece of info is that is at least double the price of a dedicated e-reader. To put it simply, you would be better off somewhere else if all you want is an e reader. Likewise, if you really want a full featured multimedia experience, you must go with iPad. It really doesn’t have any competition in this sense. A dedicated e-reader is no comparison.
In that vein, we have gathered the best of the best in e-readers to review here. The following details our observations and thoughts, and we would love for you to leave some of your own.
Kindle Kobo Nook Faceoff – The Barnes & Noble Nook
Supports: Fictionwise EPub (Non or Adobe DRM), pdb, pdf, jpg, gif, png, bmp, and mp3 files.
We didn’t find a lot to like about the Nook the first time we reviewed it. Now, several months have passed, and there have been some upgrades, but we are still not enthusiastic about it. We will acknowledge these points. Here are the good features of the Nook: Unique color touchscreen navigation, fast refreshing display screen, and good size and weight to facilitate long term reading.
There are other features that we really like, though. For example, you can “loan” an e-book to a friend for as much as two weeks at no charge. You can read e-books free of charge any time you are actually inside a Barnes and Noble store. In this situation, you can also get free or special content. Nook also features a great e-book display, including actual page numbers if you can believe that! The only other e-reader that does this is Sony.
Unfortunately, the Nook just doesn’t have the hardware power it needs. It is a novel e-reader, but it falls short in this way. Navigation of the Nook is difficult. Some kinds of technology, such as the iPod, the mouse, and so on, are easy to learn because they make sense. Not so with the Nook.
It was hard to view the book list, read books, or turn pages of a newspaper because the color touchscreen was really slow and we had to poke it a whole lot of times. Often, this got no response. The Nook also cannot display doc, txt, rtf, and other common file types. Barnes & Noble has a winner with Nook, which is very popular. It has a lot of capabilities that should spread to other e-readers in the future, but it is not our favorite.
Barnes & Noble’s Nook costs $149 and has Wi-Fi capability only. With both Wi-Fi and 3G it is $199.
Kindle Kobo Nook Faceoff – Kobo’s E-Reader
Supported formats are: Adobe DRM, ePub, pdf.
The good points include the fact that you can use the Kobo to read books from Borders’ online eBook store, but it is still high-priced and is not really a favorite. It is very comfortable to read for a long period of time because it weighs about the same as a paperback book (approximately 8 oz). Kindle comes in second on this count.
Similar to a 1st or 2nd generation iPod, the Kobo has an interface that includes 4 labeled buttons on the side as well as a directional pad. It is very simple to use. You can view all of your media by pressing HOME. You can navigate within a book by using MENU. Adjust setting from any screen with DISPLAY. Use BACK to return to the previous page or to cancel an action.
The D-pad is used for both clicking through the menu and flipping pages. You will get a blue light of acknowledgment in the top right hand corner of the frame when you hit a button. It’s something we love. Plus, you will receive 100 free e-books after you get started. Not too bad of a deal.
What does it need? Kobo had great intuitive simplicity, but it’s still the slowest of all of the e-readers we tried. Right from startup to the details such as page turns, it just is not quick. Additionally, there is no Wi-Fi or 3G to use for uploading content and you have to use a computer frequently; it does have an exposed SD card slot. It supports no audio formats and the least number of other formats.
If it didn’t cost so much (as much as other devices that have a whole lot more features) this wouldn’t be a problem. Now they have lowered the price to about $129; nonetheless, it’s still expensive. If you don’t want to read daily periodicals and you do want to have a very rugged, thin, light, easy to use eBook reader, this will work for you. We like it a lot, but the price is too high compared to the price drop of the Kindle 3.
The most recent price on the Kobo Ereader is $129 (down from $149).
Kindle Kobo Nook Faceoff – The Sony PRS-900BC Reader Daily Edition
Supports these formats: bmp, mp3, aac,jpg, png, gif, txt, rtf, doc, pdf (Non or Adobe DRM), ePub (Non or Adobe DRM).
We like the fact that it is easy to use for page turning and navigation. This is a benefit that cannot be understated. This standard of navigation has come to be expected, so it’s hard (if not impossible) to get used to anything else. Of course, fans of BlackBerry love the keypad.
The 900 works well and is easy to use. It’s not as fast or smooth as a typical smartphone touchscreen, but it’s still good. To select, poke, and to turn the pages, you swipe. There are 5 buttons located on the front for such functions as finding the home screen and switching font sizes.
Power, volume, and the wireless functionality are regulated by three others found at the top and bottom. The chassis is composed of a sturdy metal, and it comes with a sleek leather case. It turns pages briskly, and it has great interface options for reading periodicals that do not tax your vision.
The 900 is the largest of all of the e-readers in this group. It is a hulking behemoth in every way. Here are its dimensions: .5″ thick, 5″ wide, 8″ tall, with a screen that is 7.1″. Additionally, it weighs 13 oz. If you add the standard cover, it’s a bit heavier. All of this just makes this e-reader unworkable because you can’t just curl up with it and read, so what’s the point? The display is a little gray and muddy, but it can be read.
The reflective touchscreen overlay interferes a bit, and is actually a weak point for the iPad. When you put that with the price, which is nearly one and a half times the price of other models, we don’t really see the appeal. Larger, bulkier, more difficult to read, expensive? There’s bound to be fans of the 900 who will be willing to trade some features for the fact that it is the only currently available touch screen.
The Sony PRS-900BC Reader Daily Edition costs $250.
Kindle Kobo Nook Faceoff – The Amazon Kindle 3
Supports the following formats: Kindle (.AZW, .AZW1), Audible (aa, aax), bmp, pdf, mp3, txt, jpg, gif, png, html, rtf, doc, mobi, prc, and doc.
It’s poor sportsmanship to root for the frontrunner, but in all honesty, we must. We are even more excited by nearly every one of the features of the Kindle 3 than we were for the Kindle 2. It’s a lot better than previous incarnations.
It’s lighter, brighter, slimmer, and faster. It also has a longer battery life and more storage. And don’t forget that there aren’t many on the market that cost less than the WiFi version. The D-pad and the new keyboard are quite nice. The eInk screen has great contrast, in fact it practically glows in the dark.
The cons: We have very few issues, most of which have to do with E-ink in general: With the rapidfire technological growth that we have been experiencing, e-readers feel a bit like a step backwards. We do have a few complaints about it. It’s unfortunate that Kindle has no memory card slot.
Additionally, loading even the simplest document types means e-mailing them to the device. Then you have to convert them. You can’t just drag and drop them. Kindle can’t read the majority of unconverted file types; nonetheless, it is possible to drag and drop files. Kindle also doesn’t read ePub books, so you miss out on a lot of free reading. The Kindle remains the e-reader to beat in state-of-the-art technology and remains the only one we recommend without qualification.
Nook vs Kindle – It was my intention to conduct a final comparison between my Kindle 2 and the new B&N Nook. The tests I have done in the past involved me placing them next to each other and running similar operations to get a better controlled test.
Today I am unable to do that since the Nook that used to sit at the customer service desk is not there. I will see what more I can do without the refresher. (Update: They placed the Nook back and I managed a few minutes with it. I took a photo using my phone but it doesn’t show the screen very well.)
I would like to lay down some ground rules. Because this kind of posts always attract haters I need to explain that I without emotion, I set aside time to collect data and have practical experience of both devices. Comments like “Device X sucks, you are stupid” will be quickly deleted. I have brought data and science to these examinations and inconsiderate comments do not add any value to the discussions.
In comparing Nook vs Kindle I am a far cry from being called a fan and advocate of the Kindle. I conducted this comparison because one day my Kindle will not be there and if the Nook impresses me, I could adopt it as my next device. I did not approach this exercise with any foregone conclusions and I didn’t alter the data to support any unfair opinion.
So far my experiences talking to some Nook fans have been as difficult as arguing theology with a Branch Davidian. No matter how much sense you make, the conversation always ends up at the same place with Nook fans being unreasonable. I urge you to overcome any stereotypes on this blog.
Here are the results: A week ago when I first performed the tests of comparing Nook vs Kindle, each single operation on the Nook was slower than the Kindle’s. Opening a book on the Nook took 15-30 seconds while it took less than a second on the Kindle. Once the book is open, the action of page turning is slower on the Nook.
I hit the command on both devices at the same time and the page on the Kindle refreshed before the Nook’s even started. Curiously, the action of page turning backwards on the Nook is faster than going forward. However both these actions were slower than on the Kindle.
On the action of changing fonts, the Nook gives options on various fonts while the Kindle offers none. There is a downside though. Due to the increased complexity of the menus and lengthy refreshes of the book when you change the fonts, it takes 20-40 seconds for the Nook to display the new fonts. This occurs when changing both the font types and sizes. There is a dedicated button to fonts on the Kindle 2. it has a 5-way controller which allows you to select a new font size.
It takes about a second or two for the refreshed page to reflect the new changes. The 2.3 software update allows you to change between portrait and landscape modes. For me to do this and also navigate a few rows down on the menu, it took a total of 3 seconds.
I am not satisfied with the menu and the controls on the Nook. I find them difficult to use. It is true that the Nook is aiming for a higher degree of excellence but it is unable to execute.
I personally found it difficult to consistently correctly select using the touch screen. Swiping of the book covers doesn’t work well and the structure of the menu is disorganized. When I unwrapped my Kindle in March 2009, it took a little navigating for me to figure out the common operations.
I have invested half an hour with a Nook and I am not confident on how to navigate the reader. I am perplexed when listed items, such as the library management page (which is the same at the Kindle’s “Home screen”), can only move up and down from the touch screen. Page up and down controls do not function.
You could be looking at one spot but the controls want you to be at a different spot in order to manipulate them. The touch screen is narrow and with my thick fingers, I have to very keen to touch exactly what I need to. It is not the best experience.
While comparing Kindle vs Nook, it was clear that the Nook has a better contrast level on its screen. The print is clear with a light background and darker print. This works in favor of the Nook. The two devices are of the same weight and dimensions but the Nook is less lengthy and a little thicker.
It’s my perspective while comparing Kindle vs Nook that most who use these devices do not notice any variance in size or mass. I like to Tweet using the device (I have no iPhone and my Kindle is my portable connection) and love the keyboard. I think even if the Nook adds a web browser it will probably have a soft keyboard which would make it difficult to type in web addresses.
In a comparison of Kindle vs Nook I recommend against purchasing Nook 1.0. I personally have never bought Kindle 1.0 or any other gadget 1.0 because I prefer if other people break them in and discover any problems first.
I would only be interested after these problems have been fixed. I do not believe the $259 is value for money to get the Nook 1.0. Most of the problems with the device can be potentially fixed by software (like the B7N demo I used had 1.1.0 version). The Kindle’s 2.3.0 update significantly improved the device and such an update could enhance the Nook. If I was an undecided consumer, I would wait until B&N update the Nook 1.0 before I give over the cash.
Away from the comparison of the Kindle vs Nook, I would like to end with one point. Talk is floating around that Apple iTable or future applications are going to be available on the Nook because of the Android operating system. I consider it a strength and not a failure that the Kindle, Nook and Sony Reader are general purpose devices.
Even though the Kindle has a web browser, the device does one thing really well, and that is to display text to enable you to read. This device is supposed to let you sit down and read. It is possible to Tweet or check your email but it is not fun nor your first choice to do so on the Kindle as you would with a laptop, iPhone or Blackberry. This device was made to let you sit on the couch, on the beach or the seat of an airplane and read. I have enough reading material on my device that could keep me busy for two months and I would still have 1.1 gigabytes free for more.
A tablet or adding more applications to these devices wouldn’t do it for me. I am a reader and I enjoy reading but you wouldn’t known that about me in the past decade because I didn’t read for pleasure. Having this device has allows me to read and do nothing else which is a plus for me. My current needs would not be met by an e-ink version of a laptop or an iPhone.
Final score: Comparing Kindle vs Nook I prefer the Kindle but would prefer it to have a good contrast like that of the Nook. The latter has a lot of potential but I seriously recommend waiting for the software to be updated and improved before handing over your $259 to B&N.
I hope my comparison of Nook vs Kindle will also assist you in making a decision.
NOOK color vs Kindle – Many eBook readers are now available for buyers to choose from; from the utilitarian Amazon Kindle to the more flexible Nook Color, there is quite a plethora of choices. While every choice has its advantages, each one should be assessed on its own merit. We will compare the NOOK color against the Kindle 3.
NOOK color vs Kindle – Display and Readability
Depending upon what the device is being utilized for, the Nook Color is superior to the Kindle in terms of the display. While the Kindle has a black and white display, its e-ink technology doesn’t strain the eyes when reading even for long periods of time.
When one attempts to read in direct sunlight, the advantage of having an e-ink display are even more evident. Although color washout may occur on color displays and they are hard to read in lighting which is bright, e-ink displays, like the one featured on the Kindle, are glare free and easy to read.
However, the Nook’s display is ideal for reading color rich content, like magazines and children’s books, but the battery life has trouble supporting the color display. The truth is that the NOOK color only provided eight hours of reading prior to requiring to be recharged. This is totally unacceptable, particularly when the Kindle can go for a month without needing to be recharged.
NOOK color vs Kindle – Portability and Feature set
Up to this point, we have spent most of our time praising the Kindle and discussing the issues of the Nook Color, but there are good things about the Nook as well.
The NOOK color is an ereader that features a 7-inch screen display; 8GB of onboard memory; microSD slot; built-in Wireless and the Barnes & Noble Nookbook store. The gadget is able to show images and play particular audio and video formats. Additional software options should be available soon since the device runs on the Android platform, but many more should have been available when the device came to market.
The Nook and the Kindle are well-built e-readers, but the Kindle just seems more like a travel companion, partially because it weighs less than the Nook. It is debatable whether the size and weight of the Kindle is better than that of the Nook, but since the Nook is twice as heavy as the Kindle (11.2 ounces), it is easy to understand why people feel that the Kindle is the superior travel companion.
NOOK color vs Kindle – Conclusion
Both of these e-readers are built well and are highly recommended, but when trying to make a choice between the two, there are many things to consider. If you are looking for a device that can be stored easily in your luggage without any problems then the Kindle is ideal for you. You should also choose the Kindle if you want an e-reader that you can use for many days without having to recharge.
In contrast, the NOOK color is ideal for seeing color content and the majority of multimedia content available on it. You won’t hold it against people who claim that the NOOK color is a tablet, and in a way it is. While it is not really in the same league as the iPad, it performs well and the cost is less than half that of the iPad. That being said, it is possible to obtain aKindle 3 with Wi-Fi for only $139. We feel that that the Kindle is superior to the NOOK color which is only good if you need a color reader.
Nook vs Kindle 2 – Take a look at the Kindle 3 and compare it with the Nook review. This comparison of the new Kindle 3 and the Nook is the widely accepted Kindle-Nook comparative.
If you would like to learn more about the differences between Kindle 2 and Nook, kindly check out the most up to date Kindle vs Nook review which was compiled in April 2010 with major references from Nook’s third software upgrade.
Moving ahead into the Nook and Kindle 2 Review: after the announcement of the Nook, came the inclusion of Kindle PDF support, Kindle for PC is available to the public and Amazon has responded and improved on it.
• The Kindle is available at Amazon.
Nook vs Kindle 2 Comparison with Nook On Top
- LendMe – This allows your friends to borrow your Nook eBook for up to two weeks (14days). They can access it on their Nook, iPhone or personal computer. The publisher has the authority to turn off this access.
- It is an excellent feature to be able to use Nook to Nook lending allowing you to share with another Nook user.
- Overdrive Library eBooks works with Nook. The range of eBooks at libraries does not amount to much. To move to Nook you can use Adobe Digital Editions.
- Using 3.5, you can look and view various covers.
- The browser is wonderful but only operates on WiFi.
- Contains WiFi radio 802.11 b/g and is available at no cost at Barnes and Noble bookstores.
- Can expand memory with the Micro SD slot.
- Can support ePub.
- Has unique screensavers and you can personalize back covers.
- Has a battery that you can replace.
B&N carefully assessed and analyzed similar complaints given by Kindle owners which were about the memory card, the battery and lending feature.
Though B&N based their major selling point to be the LendMe feature, this was limited by Publishers.
Android can develop and success but the videos do not illustrate any extra value by its use.
Nook vs Kindle 2 Comparison Where They Both Come Out On Top
- Both Kindle and Nook have the same eInk screen
- Both have PDF support which was included as of November 24, 2009.
- The cost of bestsellers is $9.99 after B&N responded to the competitive pricing on offer by Amazon. Other than bestsellers, you can get Kindle books at an affordable cost. To get a good deal, you should compare prices at Kindle and B&N ebooks stores.
- Cost for both is currently at $259 again a response to Amazon’s pricing. Amazon has placed Kindles with the International Kindle in order to keep the price competitive.
- It appears that Nook will offer regular free eBooks just as Kindle does. Titles promoted include Maximum Ride which Kindle has offered for free before.
- Both have PC support. Kindle for PC offers multi-touch, and support for Windows XP, Vista and 7.
Recent Updates to Both Kindle and Nook
- A user now has the ability to view whole eBooks at B&N stores. There is a limitation of one hour per book in a 24 hour period and not all books are covered in this offer.
- B&N reports that there are over one million eBooks available, a majority of which are freely available to the public on Google
- The life of the battery in the Kindle 2 International has been improved by 75% leaving the Nook with a shorter battery life
- Though it is not an important difference, the Kindle is slimmer than and not as heavy as the compact Nook.
- You can only listen to mp3s on the Nook and as it doesn’t support audio books
- Though it doesn’t give Kindle much of an advantage, the dual screens and touch screen are a challenge for one handed use.
- Covers in Nook are from Kate Spade, Tahari and Jonathan Adler but Amazon only has Cole Haan.
- Kindle allows a maximum of six users on one account while Nook does not specify the limitation on how many Nooks can use one account.
- Though Sony eBooks are expensive, you can access them on Nook.
Even though B&N have 1,300 stores, it would be of benefit for people to go online and get more information on Kindle before making a decision.
Nook vs Kindle 2 Comparison With Kindle On Top
- Many reviewers have highlighted that the Kindle is faster than the Nook which is also not as easy to use. B&N have noted these observations and are trying to fix it.
- Kindle offers free access to Wikipedia from anywhere in the world.
- The Kindle has the Read To Me Text to Speech feature.
- Though the interface is not as intuitive as it should be with confusing two screens and bad menus, the Kindle is easier to use than the Nook.
- Kindle is available in over 176 countries, 81 of which have free Wikipedia and WhisperNet.
- For those who prefer a physical keyboard instead of a touch screen one, Kindle has one available.
- Books that are normally expensive at the B&N store that are non Agency Model Publishers can be accessed at a n affordable cost with Kindle.
- There are a wider variety of newspapers and magazines with Kindle.
- Kindle comes with free Internet access.
- The return conditions are more favorable with Kindle which has a return period of 30 daya with no restocking fee against Nook’s 14 day return period and 10% restocking fee.
If you are outside the US, International Kindle can still buy books while Nook cannot. If you can access Nook using WiFi, you can view newspapers and magazines for free.
Nook vs Kindle 2 Last Words…
In Nook vs Kindle 2 comparison both the Kindle and the Nook are good eBook readers. Kindle comes at an affordable value of $189 with free Interent access while Nook is WiFi enabled with a wonderful browser. Both offer good selling points.
- Choose the Kindle if any of the following is important to you: expansive range of eBooks, fast user interface, free Internet access, Read To Me feature, international WhisperNet, Wikipedia.
- Choose the Nook if any of the attributes here is what you are looking for: a good browser, extended memory, ePub support, WiFi, replaceable battery, Library eBooks support.
The final word on this comparison is that both the Kindle and Nook offer a competitive edge over the other. Though it can be said to be too close to call I believe the Kindle is ahead. it is best to analyze both and make a decision for yourself.
See more details and gain more insight on the Nook vs Kindle review which has not received any updates since 2009.
According to your preferences on features, you can be able to determine the better choice between the Nook vs Kindle 2.
Nook or Sony – GQ’s guide to the four best eReaders available:
This is a great time to be searching for an eBook reader to purchase because so many excellent choices are available, such as the Nook, iPad, Kindle and Sony eReader. In addition, since eReaders first came onto the market, a wider selection of content can be accessed, including eBooks, newspapers and Internet content.
Prices are lower, too. Be that as it may, the buyer has to figure out which reader is the best choice for purchase. The following are some considerations for determining which you prefer, the Nook or the Sony eReader.
We would have had a practically level playing field when comparing the Nook and Sony eReaders had the Nook Color not been introduced. This is especially so when you take into consideration that both readers carry a price tag of $149 and feature similar displays, however, other differences must be considered.
Nook or Sony -Display:
The display is perhaps the first thing everyone looks at. Both utilize eInk technology, which makes it easy to read comfortably for many hours, even in bright sunlight. However, the Nook’s second 3.5″ color display located at the bottom of the main display distinguishes that device from the Sony reader. This smaller display is excellent for browsing the bookstore in full color, while not consuming a great deal of battery life due to its size.
Even though the Nook possesses this outstanding feature, it is difficult to blame Sony for not doing something along the same lines, particularly since it has such a good interface of its own.
PC World’s Melissa Perenson says that Sony’s “refreshed lineup of eReaders and new touch-screen technology ups the ante over its competition.” In addition, the Nook Color provides a full 7″ LCD color display that animates color rich content that is viewed on the device.
The Nook Color is superior to the base Nook and Sony reader for all uses, including reading magazines and newspapers, due to its color display. The Nook Color is not as easy to read in bright light and its battery does not last very long (only 8 hours in comparison to the standard Nook that has a battery life of 10 days).
Nook or Sony – Selection of Books:
Whether one is purchasing a Nook or a Sony eReader, one of the primary considerations should be the quantity of content (magazines, books, apps) that the reader can access.
Barnes & Noble has relied on book sales for its profits since its inception many years ago, so it comes as no surprise that they provide hundreds of thousands of books in their online store. This is a number against which Sony just cannot compete at this point in time. Since these two eReaders provide formats like EPUB and PDF, what types of books and information are available for downloading? These two formats allow millions of free books to be available for checkout from public libraries. However, Nook’s LendMe™ technology gives that device an edge over the Sony.
Barnes & Noble is the only one offering this technology, making it possible to ‘lend’ out a book for two weeks. When the book is loaned, it shows up on the friend’s Nook Color. Once the loan period has expired, the book is automatically returned to the lender’s library, with neither party incurring any charges.
Nook or Sony – Wireless:
It would be inconvenient to have to attach your eReader to your computer whenever you want to transfer files, so the reader you select should include some type of wireless service. It is possible to get the entry level Nook with both 3G and Wi-Fi, but the 3G will cost you a bit more. Luckily, free data service is included with the 3G service that you will have to purchase for $50.
Nook or Sony – Conclusion:
All the Nook and Sony eReaders will do a good job. They are all small enough to transport comfortably and utilize each day to read books, newspapers and web content. Solid interfaces are present on all devices and overall permit a satisfactory user experience.
Having said that, I still believe any version of the Nook is a better choice than the Sony reader due to the vast quantity of content that is accessible via the Barnes & Noble eBook store and their LendMe technology.
Sony vs Kindle reader – The Evolution of eBook Readers
Many technological devices have been developed to help automate many of our daily activities. These days we can get onto the Internet, do our banking and shopping online and keep in touch with others using social networking sites and apps, plus people are reducing their carbon footprint while doing so. This is just the reasoning for creating eBook readers.
eReaders provide an environmentally sound method for reading any kind of media utilizing an electronic device. This means that people no longer have to carry around stacks of books and magazines, plus, fewer trees have to be cut down in order to provide paper to manufacture these books and magazines.
With an eBook reader, it is possible to store and access hundreds of books and other printed media on a flat, rectangular device. Not only does an outstanding eBook reader allow you to access books, but also it allows you to do so with a minimum of effort. It also provides a large, clear screen and long battery life. The Sony eBook Reader and the Kindle are two of the most popular of these. Both these have multiple features, details and additional worth taking notice of and comparing.
Sony vs Kindle reader – Similar Features
The Sony eBook Reader against Kindle competition has accelerated over the last period of time, trying to determine which model is the best. They are very similar, despite being developed by two very different companies.
To begin with, both devices utilize the same display technology, similar microprocessors and storage modes, both internal and external. Also, both product’s battery life can work for one week on a full charge. They also share many common characteristics, such as default fonts, and their ability to zoom. Even though these two eBook Readers are somewhat alike, they are also dissimilar in many ways.
Sony vs Kindle reader – Touch ScreenTechnology
Although both devices utilize E-Ink technology, differences exist between their touch screen facilities. Sony has 2 eBook readers with varying touchscreens: the Daily Edition and Touch Edition. The Daily Edition’s touchscreen is 7 inches, and the Touch Edition comes in at a smaller 6 inches.
The Kindle eBook reader interface can be altered and accessed through hardware buttons. You can turn the page, change the text size and add text with the cell phone like buttons. Newer versions of the Sony reader include the choice of altering, editing, and manipulating media with a touchscreen interface.
Sony vs Kindle reader – Lifetimes
Since its creation, the Kindle only has two eBook reader versions, and Sony is on its third generation. While one outstanding release may provide a project that is superior even after a competitor produces three other inferior products, Sony’s recent third generation with its new features has allowed the Sony to pull ahead of the Kindle.
Sony vs Kindle reader – Free Access to Media and Wireless Connectivity
A computer is not needed by the Kindle eBook device in order to access the Internet since it includes an EVDO cellular 3G connection for Sprint users to the Internet. The Kindle 2 provides a cost free Internet and access to Wikipedia. Its users can get readable media less expensively, and its online store offers a number of books, magazines and blogs from which users can select.
Sony’s eBook reader doesn’t have wireless Internet capabilities. This results in having to download books from a PC to the reader before accessing them. The Sony Reader might not be the top choice for those who want to use the internet and read books at their convenience.
Sony vs Kindle reader – Extra Features
Sony eBook reader includes a built in PDF reader, which the Kindle does not, which makes downloading and reading PDF’s easy. The Kindle cannot do this as it needs PDFs to be formatted into Mobipocket format. The majority of individuals find this to be too much work and choose not to get a Kindle. Dropping or jarring a Kindle is less damaging, due to its built-in shock protection. Sony’s device doesn’t come with shock absorption, so users must be particularly careful.
Sony vs Kindle reader – Summary
The eBook Reader by Sony, compared to Kindle competition has its plusses and minuses. Where one device might have a flaw, another might compensate for it. Both devices are fairly creative and original in their attempts to offer eco-friendly products and useful devices. It all boils down to an individual’s personal preferences. That’s how they can tell whether Sony’s sleek touchscreen reader or the second version of the Kindle is right for them.